National Championship at Richmond Yacht ClubSeptember 28 - 30
Result
PosBoatTotalRace 1Race 2Race 3Race 4Race 5
1Shenanigans102(2)3(5)1(6)2(8)2 (10)
2Wile E Coyote173(3)1(4)3(7)6(13)4 (17)
3El Raton231(1)5(6)8(14)1(15)8 (23)
4Get Happy234(4)4(8)5(13)4(17)6 (23)
5Freaks ona Leash285(5)7(12)6(18)7(25)3 (28)
6Peaches367(7)8(15)4(19)3(22)14 (36)
7Magic Bus406(6)2(8)7(15)OCS(39)1 (40)
8Motorcycle Irene4810(10)DNC(34)2(36)5(41)7 (48)
9Ergo498(8)14(22)12(34)10(44)5 (49)
10Opa!579(9)6(15)OCS(39)8(47)10 (57)
11Monster Express5713(13)9(22)11(33)12(45)12 (57)
12Dianne5711(11)15(26)9(35)9(44)13 (57)
13Great White5918(18)11(29)10(39)11(50)9 (59)
14Take Five7015(15)10(25)14(39)13(52)18 (70)
15Libra7314(14)13(27)15(42)16(58)15 (73)
16Fired Up!7619(19)18(37)13(50)15(65)11 (76)
17Elise8112(12)12(24)17(41)DNF(65)16 (81)
18Wetsu8216(16)16(32)16(48)17(65)17 (82)
19Bobs8920(20)20(40)21(61)OCS(85)DNC (109)
20Archimedes9517(17)17(34)18(52)DNF(76)19 (95)
21Chile Dog97DNF(24)19(43)19(62)14(76)21 (97)
22Summer Palace10621(21)21(42)20(62)DNC(86)20 (106)
23Witchy Woman120DNC(24)DNC(48)DNC(72)DNC(96)DNC(120)
export csv

Regatta Message Board

Reply | Post New Message | All Messages | this message is spam
Author: Bob Harvey
Subject: Oh,?, why is scoring 2nd silly?
Info: (15508 views) Posted: Saturday 12-6-08 09:29:43 PM
Take two races ... there's two boats entered in one and ten in the other. Does it feel fair to you that second place in those two races should count the same?

Low point works well in a regatta where there's the same number of boats in all the races. When you're talking about a series made up of different events, it's unlikely you'll get equal numbers. The boat that takes second out of ten boats won't enjoy getting equal series credit with the boat who took second out of two.

I know that's an extreme example, but it effectively shows the 'silliness' (I hope).

Bob

:: Hi Bob:
::
:: One question. Why in a low point system is scoring the
:: second place boat 2nd silly? Appears on the surfance to
:: be level method across a series. Where and how does this
:: system fail to encourage series participation?
::
:: Thanks,

:: mb

Reply | Post New Message | All Messages | this message is spam